Compare and contrast the experiences of Robyn Kina and Daisy Li. Was linguicism a problem for both women?
Need to write 600 words essay after reading 4 articles, the essay needs to be in concessional styles of argument
These are the 4 texts and case studies we are looking at, and responding to, for the WT2. Note that each is relevant to Linguicism, but that the focus is on the two individuals: Robyn Kina and Daisy Li.
Instructions for the WT2 and question:
Key themes are:
- Language discrimination is discussed in all 4 texts.
- The term for this type of discrimination is Linguicism.
- Accent and non-standard grammars are areas where people feel either in control or powerless.
- Real social disadvantage is the result of language discrimination.
- Daisy Li experiences emotional and social isolation, but Robyn Kina experiences real physical harm (incarceration and violence).
All of these texts model persuasiveness, but the scholarly texts are longer and more difficult to read.
Incidents of discrimination are common, but systematic, or chronic social disadvantage is a real fact of life for many people.
Racism may be a factor in each of these instances, but accent and non-standard grammar are also features of English for people who may be ethnically part of the majority.
Key requirements of the WT2:
- Some referencing, improving on the WT1 effort.
- Refer to, reference, and integrate all 4 texts in your response.
Binary approach: - use opposing arguments and evidence.
- 500-600 word limit.
- Clearer essay structure, with introduction, body paragraphs and conclusion.
- Explicitly refer to the experiences of Robyn Kina and Daisy Li.