Evidence in Health Assessment 2: Evidence Selection Template
Evidence in Health Assessment 2: Evidence Selection Template
Student name: Shivsamarjit Kaur Student ID: 22035650
Section 1: PICO and search strategy
You work with sporting teams to manage health and injuries. You have always used static stretching but now you question if this is the best way to prevent injuries for the soccer team you work with. Find the best available evidence to inform you as to whether pre-exercise static stretching is likely to be effective for preventing injuries in this team.
Evidence Question: .
Is pre-exercise static stretching effective in preventing injuries in a soccer team?Support your answer with an evidence.
PICO
Complete the following table.
Soccer player/ Soccer /Football player
Population soccer teams
Intervention
Doing Static stretching before performance
Comparison
Static stretching
Outcome
Improves performance
Search Strategy
Copy or use screenshot of search strategy. It must be readable.
Section 2: Evidence selection criteria
Complete the following table
Selection criteria Evidence 1
Journal Title: Indian journal of physiotherapy and occupational therapy Evidence 2
Journal Title:Static Stretching at Pain Evidence 3
Journal Title:
Type of evidence/research design
A study was conducted to research the effects of static and no stretch warm up with evidence and methods they tried
Experimented information with methods/evidence
Talks about prevention of injury with evidence and information about static stretching how it effects that.
Level of evidence
Quantitive Quantitative and qualitative Qualitative
Recency Level 3 Level 3 Level 2
Relevance to evidence question
It is relevance to the question as it conducts the effect of doing static stretching before and not doing. It is relevance as it explains how stretching exercise are used in soccer compared to other exercise type which are explained in the article It is relevant to the question as it talks about prevention of injury by performing static stretching
Section 3: Evidence justification
In 100 words, justify your choice of one article (Evidence 1) as best available evidence that contributes to answering the evidence question.
Journal 1
This journal/article conducts warm up routines which showcases the effectiveness of static stretching compared to other stretching techniques. It is explained that a soccer player should be doing dynamic stretching and should be included in soccer players' warm routines. There are methods and evidence that showcases which one is better. They both are beneficial but oil their own ways but when it comes to soccer players dynamic stretching is more preferable then static as the study shows in the article The results has shown that dynamic stretching has significant enhancement in measure of power compared to static stretching.
Reference List
Reference your three articles here.
Babbar, S; Zutshi, K; Munjal, J Indian Journal of Physiotherapy & Occupational Therapy, Apr-June2011; 5(2): 141-143. 3p. (Journal Article - research, tables/charts)
https://web-s-ebscohost-com.ezproxy.uws.edu.au/ehost/viewarticle/render?data=dGJyMPPp44rp2%2fdV0%2bnjisfk5Ie46bJQta%2b0Tbak63nn5KyF49rxfd%2fo4YC%2brq1Kt6WwSLConkmwsLNJuKu2OM7DpIzw1%2byL39nyge3k53y7o7NIrq6ySbKrtz7x3%2bJV46vhTbWnrk6r2LN85KOyfrTXq1Hhrq5F46bhSbSsr1Gyr%2bB5vujjfOfppITf5OVV4%2bSkfOCz8JLmnPJ55bO%2fZqTX7FWvprJOtaawS66c5Ifw49%2bMu9zzhOrq45Dy&vid=5&sid=e5c57106-b5df-4f6a-9c80-e0c1661949ba@redisWSU Library - Main EZproxy. (n.d.). login.ezproxy.uws.edu.au. Retrieved August 29, 2022, from https://web-s-ebscohost-com.ezproxy.uws.edu.au/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?vid=3&sid=fcf9f31b-83d7-4b2c-b063-09055d391066%40redisWSU Library - Main EZproxy. (n.d.). Login.ezproxy.uws.edu.au. https://www-ncbi-nlm-nih-gov.ezproxy.uws.edu.au/pmc/articles/PMC3685153/Abstracts
Copy or scan the abstract (or first page) of each evidence article and
Article 1-3 attach here. The attachment must be readable.
