ACCT3001 - Marking Rubric for Portfolio written report
ACCT3001 - Marking Rubric for Portfolio written report
Criteria Below Expectations Below expectations Meet Expectations (pass) Exceeds Expectations Exceeds Expectations
Purpose and Objective
Total: 2 marks
0 Marks
The purpose and objective of the report are not stated. 0.5 Mark
Only the purpose or objective of the report is mentioned 1 Marks
The purpose and objective of the report are mentioned but not clearly expressed. 1.5 Marks
The purpose and objective of the report are mentioned and clearly expressed 2 marks
The purpose and objective of the report are clearly stated and the report addressed the objective in a focused and logical manner.
Identification and justification of the performance measures used in the Balanced scorecard
Total: 8 marks 0 Marks
The performance measures identified are incorrect/broad/irrelevant and no Justification is provided. 2 Marks
Discipline knowledge is poorly applied,
very few specific & relevant performance measures are correctly identified and clearly justified. 4 Marks
Applies appropriate discipline knowledge, specific &relevant
performance measures are correctly identified but the justification of answer is unclear/illogical. 6 marks
Applies appropriate discipline knowledge, specific and
relevant performance measures are correctly identified and the justification of answer is clear and logical. 8 marks
Applies appropriate discipline knowledge, specific and
relevant performance measures are correctly identified and provides clear, logical, and convincing justification.
Balanced Scorecard implementation - challenges and recommendation.
Total: 3 marks 0 Marks
The issues are not identified/incorrect. 1 Mark
The issues are stated and described, but with insufficient/irrelevant information for an adequate understanding. 1.5 Marks
the issues are stated clearly and described, with sufficient and relevant information for an adequate understanding. 2 marks
The issues are stated clearly and described thoroughly and deliver most relevant information necessary for a full understanding. 3 marks
The issues are stated clearly and described comprehensively.
(delivering all relevant information necessary for a full understanding)
The explanation of individual-based and group-based incentives
Total: 3 marks
0 Marks
The issues are not identified/incorrect. 1 Mark
The issues are stated and described, but with insufficient/irrelevant information for an adequate understanding. 1.5 Marks
the issues are stated clearly and described, with sufficient and relevant information for an adequate understanding. 2 marks
The issues are stated clearly and described thoroughly and deliver most relevant information necessary for a full understanding. 3 marks
The issues are stated clearly and described comprehensively.
(delivering all relevant information necessary for a full understanding)
Writing skills: spelling, grammar, punctuation, etc.
Total: 2 marks
0 Marks
Numerous spelling errors, non-existent or incorrect punctuation, and /or severe errors in grammar that interfere with understanding. 0.5 Mark
Occasional lapses in spelling, punctuation, and grammar but not enough to seriously distract the reader. 1 Mark
Few spelling errors, correct punctuation, and sentences are grammatically correct and complete. 1.5 Mark
Very few spelling errors, correct punctuation, and sentences are grammatically correct and complete. 2 marks
Error-free, correct punctuation, and sentences are grammatically correct and complete.
Structure & Presentation: title page, table of contents, conclusion, referencing, also refers to the look of the report.
Total: 2 marks 0 Marks
Key elements of the business report are not provided. Overall presentation of the document is not to a professional standard. 0.5 Mark
A few key elements of the business report are provided. Overall presentation of the document is not to a professional standard. 1 Marks
Most key elements of the business report are provided. Overall presentation of the document is not to a professional standard.
1.5 Marks
All required elements of the business report are present and completed to a satisfactory standard. Attention to the presentation is given, but may not be well-executed.
2 Marks
All required elements of the business report are present and completed to a high standard. The document is presented in a professional-looking document, using informative headings
