CRI20001 Policing: Systems and Practice
Introduction
Victoria, Australia's policing is inhibited by multiple modern problems that greatly influence its goals and efficiency (Harrison et al., 2020). The two biggest problems would be police accountability & standards and police policing of minorities. Police accountability and standards are vital for the public trust, honest exercise and policing justice. Conversely, policing multicultural communities entails culturally sensitive methods which promote cooperation and trust across cultural and ethnic borders. This particular essay critically reviews these two problems with pertinent criminological theories, practice and policy examples. By determining today's measures 'strengths and weaknesses and suggesting areas for improvement the study will try to understand the effect of these challenges on police services in Victoria. The objective is highlighting the need for continuous change and adaptation to focus community demands and also to raise the overall efficiency and authenticity of the police force. In this particular crucial conversation, it becomes apparent that addressing these problems is vital to developing a far more accountable, transparent and community oriented model of policing in Victoria.
Main Body
Section 1: Police Accountability and Standards
Police accountability and standards are crucial to the operation and productivity of police forces. Very high standards and accountability are vital for public trust, law and police credibility in Victoria, Australia. This particular section significantly reviews today's police accountability and requirements in Victoria, identifies the primary difficulties, talks about related theoretical perspectives and offers policy and training examples. The study identifies the strengths and weaknesses of existing measures and also proposes areas for improvement.
Victoria: Current State
Victoria has created mechanisms for police accountability and standards. A crucial oversight body will be the Independent Broad-based Anti-Corruption Commission (IBAC), which is tasked with examining suspected patterns of severe police misconduct and corruption. The Victoria Police Professional Standards Command (PSC) also maintains internal accountability with the investigation of complaints against officers and checks against ethics standards. Regardless of these frameworks, recent incidents have doubted the usefulness of them. Police misconduct, which includes racial profiling and excessive force, has undercut public trust in the police force (Rad, Kirk & Jones, 2023). For instance, its examination of Victoria Police officers' actions during the 2020 COVID-19 lockdowns discovered questionable behaviour and excessive force, highlighting accountability failures.
Challenges & Issues
Many barriers prevent police accountability and standards being efficiently delivered in Victoria. A key problem is the obvious lack of transparency in the investigation along with the disciplinary processes. Though PSC and IBAC are accountable for police behaviour, they're accused of being opaque and slow, therefore creating a feeling of insufficient accountability. Victims and the public frequently grumble about being uninformed regarding the results of disciplinary actions and investigations against officers prosecuted for misconduct. An additional main hurdle would be the police attitude of resistance. The Blue wall of silence' - a term describing the informal code police officers often adopt to shield their colleagues from questioning often hinders accountability (Moran, 2023). This particular silence could deter officers reporting misconduct and impede investigation therefore corroborate the efficiency of the accountability systems set up. You will find worries about insufficient training and education of police officers. Officers should be educated in areas of ethics, human rights, and force for high standards and good accountability. However, reports have pointed to inadequacies in Victoria Police education courses such as cultural de-escalation and competence.
Theoretical Perspectives
Criminological theoretical frameworks offer insights into police accountability and standards challenges. For example, procedural justice theory stresses fairness in results. This particular theory argues in case individuals think that they're being treated fairly by authorities, then authorities tend to be reliable and follow their instructions. Concerning policing out of this particular concept, it explains that open and transparent investigative procedures are crucial to keeping public confidence and increasing police legitimacy (Oliveira & Jackson, 2021). An additional related theory will be the deterrence theory, which says that individuals are not as likely to commit misconduct in case they expect the consequences to be severe, certain, and swift. This particular concept emphasises the need for robust discipline methods & timely and transparent investigations to avoid police misconduct.
Example of policy and practice
Victoria has a variety of procedures and procedures to enhance police accountability and standards. The development of IBAC itself is a crucial step towards independent supervision. IBAC is authorised to hold public examinations and thus enhance transparency and public awareness of its activities. Body-worn cameras for law enforcement officers are also a practical method to increase accountability by capturing police conversations with the public objectively. Nonetheless, these measures have proved mixed in usefulness. Body-worn cameras have really helped in certain cases but aren't needed in most conversations and concerns surround when and how the video is utilised (Belur et al., 2020). Additionally, IBAC's capability and information are questioned with some critics indicating the commission lacks both power and funding to police force supervision.
Critical analysis
Analysing today's accountability measures for weaknesses and strengths. Independent examination by oversight bodies like IBAC is a welcomed change. Transparency problems, societal opposition and inadequate training not to mention that the present systems aren't enough for preventing and reacting to police misconduct. Transparency of investigation and discipline is but one area of improvement (Valdez et al., 2020). This might involve routine public reporting of disciplinary actions and investigation, therefore enhancing public trust of the accountability mechanisms. Also, enhancing the independence and resources of oversight bodies like IBAC would permit more complete and timely investigations.
Cultural problems inside the army also must be dealt with. Steps to break the blue wall of silence - along with anonymous reporting and whistleblower protections methods - can motivate officers to report misconduct fearless of retribution. Moreover, establishing a culture of accountability through leadership and education that stresses ethical behaviour and accountability may end up in positive reinforcement from within the force. One more significant reform goal is the training and education of police officers. Training officers in areas of morality, human rights, cultural de-escalation and competence can bring down misconduct and also enhance relations with the general public (Bennell et al., 2022). Officer refresher classes and assessments might offer ongoing updates on best practices and values.
Section 2: Policing Diverse Communities
Policing officers facing diverse communities have unique opportunities and challenges to patrol them. Victoria, Australia the population of Victoria is multi-ethnic and multicultural, therefore policing here should be nuanced and culturally sensitive. Policing in such contexts is crucial for trust, public safety and good relationships between police and the community (Nyborg & Lohmann, 2020). This particular chapter significantly reviews the present practice of policing diverse communities in Victoria, identifies the main problems, talks about related theoretical approaches and offers policy and training examples. The analysis finds today's strategies 'strengths and weak points and also proposes areas for improvement.
Victoria: Current State
Victoria is among Australia's most multicultural states, with a lot of Victoria's population being born overseas and primarily speaking languages apart from English in their home. Victoria Police have followed strategies to accommodate this diverse society like multicultural liaison officers, community engagement programmes and officer cultural competence training. Nonetheless, challenges continue. It comes amid reports that numerous minorities distrust the police due to fears of racial profiling and 'biassed treatment'. As an example, the African Australian community has complained about unfair targeting and racial policing (McGinnity et al., 2021). Such problems underscore the continuing fight for just and effective policing throughout all community organisations in Victoria.
Challenges & issues
Several key challenges prevent diverse communities from properly policing Victoria. Racial discrimination and profiling are but one significant problem. Reports of increased rates of police stops and searches, usually without explanation, among minorities like Africans, Middle Eastern and Indigenous peoples. This alienates these groups and in addition undermines the power of the police. Mistakes regarding cultural understandings and bad cultural competence amongst law enforcement officers intensify these issues even more (Dempsey, Eskander & Dubljevi?, 2023). Law enforcement officers should understand cultural norms, values and styles of communication to properly police diverse communities. But confusion and confrontation ensue since a lot of officers are reportedly not effectively trained in these areas. For instance, culturally normative gestures or actions for many communities could be viewed as potentially distrustful or even threats by police officers. An additional hurdle may be the institutional and historical dynamics of police versus minority distrust. Current police community relationships are still coloured by historic injustices including Aboriginal Australian abuse. This particular historical context indicates that trust building initiatives should transcend shallow steps and confront bigger systemic inequality and bias.
Theoretical perspectives
Many criminological concepts provide insight into policing various peoples. The theory of community policing stresses the need to establish strong police - community relations. This particular theory states that police should talk to individuals, listen to them and solve issues together. This strategy is especially pertinent in multicultural societies where trust and cooperation are crucial for policing. Perspectives derived from social work likewise become cultural competence theory. This particular theory asserts that good service delivery in multicultural settings calls for practitioners to accept their very own cultural biases, analyse the cultural context of the clients and alter their training accordingly (Arango & Lustig, 2023). To translate this particular idea into police implies officers should be educated in cultural competence and need to be continuously studying their communities.
Example of practice and policy
Victoria Police have created a variety of policies and programs to encourage closer relationships with communities. One particular effort consists of the development of multicultural liaison officers. These police officers serve like a link in between the police and various ethnic groups, promoting interaction and understanding. Community involvement programs which include forums and outreach functions also allow for dialogue and cooperation between police and community members. An additional initiative will be the cultural and diversity training program, which instructs police officers to cope with individuals coming from various backgrounds (Cnat et al., 2024). This course covers topics including cultural awareness, bias recognition, and powerful communication methods. The value of such training courses is however usually questioned. Critics point out one-time instruction as inadequate and ongoing education and encouragement is necessary for permanent change. More jurisdictional case studies offer further details. In the UK for instance, the Met police Service has introduced "Listening Circles" - police officers enrolling in local individuals in order to discuss problems and to create trust. Such programs emphasize ongoing dialogue and relations among communities.
Critical analysis
Assessing current strategy performance determines weaknesses & areas for improvement. The existence of multicultural liaison officers and community engagement schemes raise issues around cultural competence and community relations. Such programs offer great opportunities for communication and communication among police and communities. The present racial tension and discriminatory behaviour to have a bigger systemic change. To deal with these problems a holistic approach comprising policy reforms, organizational culture shift and education is required (Goudard et al., 2020). For instance, stricter guidelines and supervision to stop racial profiling alongside periodic audits and reviews may lessen discrimination.
One more possible improvement area is cultural competence education of policing officers. Continuing education personnel might be ready to involve people from one-time programs to continuing. This kind of training courses might additionally be enhanced by including role play and community immersion as helpful features. Trusting minority groups calls for dealing with past and institutional obstacles. This involves admitting previous mistakes, starting important dialogue and openness with affected people (Vian, 2020). Setting up independent oversight bodies to monitor accountability and police behaviour may also develop trust in the police force.
Conclusion
In Victoria, Australia, new modern problems of standards and police accountability highlight policing through community diversity as a significant challenge for effective and authentic police. Current frameworks including IBAC oversight body and multicultural liaison officer initiatives show cultural competence and transparency. Nevertheless, lasting issues such as for instance racial profiling, cultural misperceptions and systemic distrust need systemic change across several dimensions. Using criminological theories such as for instance procedural justice and community policing highlights the demand for fairness, good community relations and transparency in policing. Additional cultural competency training, openness in investigation along with a police culture of responsibility are required first steps towards genuine progress. To create trust with diverse individuals entails admitting earlier wrongdoings, implementing extensive reforms, and also ensuring constant engagement and dialogue with all individuals in the society. Looking at all these problems holistically will allow Victoria Police to attain a far more inclusive, community-based and accountable policing model which retains public safety and motivates trust between communities and police it serves. This plan is crucial in developing a good and just police process in Victoria.
Are you struggling to keep up with the demands of your academic journey? Don't worry, we've got your back!
Exam Question Bank is your trusted partner in achieving academic excellence for all kind of technical and non-technical subjects. Our comprehensive range of academic services is designed to cater to students at every level. Whether you're a high school student, a college undergraduate, or pursuing advanced studies, we have the expertise and resources to support you.
To connect with expert and ask your query click here Exam Question Bank
