NURS6900 Assessment 1: Critique of Literature Review

1. Review Question and Objectives (Approx 100 words)

JBI Checklist Question: Is the review question clearly and explicitly stated? What is the purpose, objective, and/or question of the systematic review?

1. GenAI response:

1. GenAI Error: Describe any errors or inaccuracies in GenAI's critique related to the review question and objectives.

3. Correction: Did the research question meet the methodological criteria for this type of literature review? Use further literature to support your answer.

2. Inclusion Criteria (Approx 100 words)

JBI Checklist Question: What are the inclusion criteria for this review? Are the inclusion criteria appropriate for the review question? Explain why/why not.

1. GenAI response:

1. GenAI Error: Identify and explain any errors in GenAI's assessment of the inclusion criteria.

3. Correction: Did the inclusion criteria meet methodological standards for this type of literature review? Use further literature to support your answer.

3. Search Strategy (Approx 100 words)

JBI Checklist Question: Is a clear search strategy provided? Is the search strategy appropriate? Explain why/why not.

1. GenAI response:

1. GenAI Error: Describe any mistakes in GenAI's critique of the search strategy.

3. Correction: Was the search strategy correct for the type of literature review employed? Use further literature to support your answer.

4. Sources and Resources for Article Search (Approx 100 words)

JBI Checklist Question: What sources and resources were used to search for articles? Explain if the sources and resources are adequate.

1. GenAI response:

1. GenAI Error: Identify any errors in GenAI's critique regarding sources and resources used.

3. Correction: Were the sources used by the authors appropriate for the literature research design? Use further literature to support your answer.

5. Criteria for Appraising Studies (Approx 100 words)

JBI Checklist Question: What was the criteria for appraising studies? Was this criteria appropriate? Provide a rationale for your answer.

1. GenAI response:

1. GenAI Error: Note any irregularities in the GenAI critique about the criteria for appraising studies.

3. Correction: Did the appraisal tools used fit the type of literature review design used by the authors? Use further literature to support your answer.

6. Independent Critical Appraisal (Approx 100 words)

JBI Checklist Question: Was critical appraisal conducted by two or more reviewers independently? Explain why it is important to have two or more reviewers.

1. GenAI response:

1. GenAI Error: Describe any discrepancies in GenAIs critique of the independent critical appraisal process.

3. Correction: Was the appraisal approach adequate for the type of research design used? Use further literature to support your answer.

7. Data Extraction Methods (Approx 100 words)

JBI Checklist Question: How was the data extracted? What methods were used to minimize errors in data extraction? Are these methods appropriate? Explain.

1. GenAI response:

2. GenAI Error: Identify mistakes in the critique related to data extraction methods.

3. Correction: Did the data extraction method used by the authors fit with the type of literature review design? Use further literature to support your answer.

8. Methods for Combining Studies (Approx 100 words)

JBI Checklist Question: Were the methods used to combine studies appropriate? Provide a rationale for your answer.

1. GenAI response:

1. GenAI Error: Highlight any inaccuracies in GenAIs assessment of the methods used for combining studies.

3. Correction: Using literature from other sources, explain whether the method used to combine the studies and discuss the results was appropriate for the literature review design.

9. Assessment of Publication Bias (Approx 100 words)

JBI Checklist Question: Was the likelihood of publication bias assessed? Provide a rationale for your answer.

1. GenAI response:

1. GenAI Error: Identify any errors in GenAIs critique on the assessment of publication bias.

3. Correction: Describe the possible publication bias implications for this literature review using evidence from other literature to support your statements.

10. Support for Recommendations (Approx 100 words)

JBI Checklist Question: Were recommendations for policy and/or practice supported by the reported data? Explain how.

1. GenAI response:

1. GenAI Error: Note any inconsistencies in GenAIs critique of support for recommendations.

3. Correction: Correct and justify using the reviews data. Use further literature to support your answer.

11. Directives for New Research (Approx 100 words)

JBI Checklist Question: Were specific directives for new research identified? Are these appropriate? Provide a rationale for your answer.

1. GenAI response:

1. GenAI Error: Identify any errors in GenAI's critique regarding new research directives.

3. Correction: Was the recommended future research approaches appropriate for the style of literature review used in this study? Use further literature to support your answer.

12. Application of Findings to Clinical Practice (Approx 100 words)

JBI Checklist Question: From your appraisal of this review, would you apply the findings to your clinical practice? Explain why/why not.

1. GenAI response:

1. GenAI Error: Identify any errors in GenAIs critique regarding the application of findings to clinical practice.

3. Correction: Use evidence from other sources to explain your enthusiasm or hesitancy to use the findings of this study in your clinical practice. Use further literature to support your answer.