ASSESSMENT 3 (Peer-Review of 2 case studies)
ASSESSMENT 3 (Peer-Review of 2 case studies)
Your name: __________________________Your ID: _____________
Case study number: 1
Section A (highlight or bold your response)
1. Overall structure (select one):
Unclear Vague Organised Very well structured
2. Demonstrates good theoretical knowledge on the problem presented (select one):
Poor Fair Good Very Good Excellent
3. Contains relevant information showing insight in the problem. The solution offered is based on theoretical background and scientific analysis (select one):
Poor Fair Good Very Good Excellent
4. Shows ability to plan and complete all parts of a written report that fit into the requirements of reporting the case (select one):
Poor Fair Good Very Good Excellent
5. Meets the standards of technical writing (select one):
Poor Fair Good Very Good Excellent
6. Your overall impression (select one):
Poor Fair Good Very Good Excellent
7. General aspects of the report (select only if apply, you can select more than one):
Too hurriedly written
Report not set out in formal order
Poor spelling
Poor grammar
Difficult to follow arguments: muddled, disorganized
Section B
Personal comments/considerations (approx. 250 words)
Case study number: 2
Section A (highlight or bold your response)
1. Overall structure (select one):
Unclear Vague Organised Very well structured
2. Demonstrates good theoretical knowledge on the problem presented (select one):
Poor Fair Good Very Good Excellent
3. Contains relevant information showing insight in the problem. The solution offered is based on theoretical background and scientific analysis (select one):
Poor Fair Good Very Good Excellent
4. Shows ability to plan and complete all parts of a written report that fit into the requirements of reporting the case (select one):
Poor Fair Good Very Good Excellent
5. Meets the standards of technical writing (select one):
Poor Fair Good Very Good Excellent
6. Your overall impression (select one):
Poor Fair Good Very Good Excellent
7. General aspects of the report (select only if apply, you can select more than one):
Too hurriedly written
Report not set out in formal order
Poor spelling
Poor grammar
Difficult to follow arguments: muddled, disorganized
Section B
Personal comments/considerations (approx. 250 words)
